Tuesday, March 17, 2009

Reality Czech: Frozen Smelly T-shirts


Back in graduate school a buddy of mine was doing a clinical psychology internship. One day he interviewed an elderly couple—the wife complained that her husband was getting forgetful and confused. “How so?” asked my friend. “Well,” said the wife, “last week I found a pair of his underwear in the ice cube tray in the refrigerator.”

It turns out there are reasons other than Alzheimer’s dementia for people to want to freeze underwear. Take body odor researchers, for example. A standard method for collecting BO is to have the odor donor wear a T-shirt for a couple of days. The BO-infused shirt is a handy scent source—test subjects can rate it for strength and pleasantness of smell, how masculine or feminine it smells, and so on. A popular alternative method is to have the donor wear cotton armpit pads to collect the perspiration.

In BO research one often wants to use multiple samples from the same donor and to have more than one set of judges rate the same odor. The logistics of this can get tricky—a couple of dozen panelists have to arrive at the same time as a group of odor donors delivers the dirty laundry. The easy way out is to store the smelly shirts for testing at a more convenient time. Researchers often put the shirts or pads in plastic bags and freeze them. The rationale is that freezing inhibits the bacteria that turn odorless fresh sweat into stinky BO.

Does this practice work?  Could it distort experimental results in some unexpected way? We had no direct answer to these questions until now. A pair of Czech BO scientists—Pavlina Lenochova and Jan Havlicek in Prague—along with S. Craig Roberts at Liverpool in the UK, examined how freezing—and repeated freezing-and-thawing—affect smell ratings of cotton armpit pads worn by male BO donors.

The upshot of the study, published in the journal Chemical Senses, is that the pleasantness, attractiveness, and masculinity of the samples were unaffected by two weeks or even six months of frozen storage. (The odor judges were 28 young women.) There were some variations in odor intensity but puzzlingly they were not related to storage time.

So the underwear-in-the-freezer gambit looks like an excellent solution to your BO storage needs. As a smell scientist, I can breathe easier knowing this.

Sunday, March 15, 2009

Proust With an Anal Probe: The Smells of an Alien Abduction


Marcel Proust’s mistaken ideas about smell memory have soaked deeply into popular culture—so deep they are used to support the authenticity of alien abduction stories.

Whitley Strieber’s Communion: A true story (1987) is the narrative of his abduction by aliens in a UFO, followed by his realization under hypnosis that such visitations had been occurring throughout his life. While Strieber remained coy about whether his “visitors” were, in fact, extraterrestrials, most readers made the leap and drove the book to #1 on the New York Times bestseller list (in nonfiction!). Two years later it became a movie with Strieber played by Christopher Walken.

The details of Strieber’s story emerged only under hypnosis. According to the “recovered memories” crowd and the Freudians who aid and abet their nonsense, memories that have to be teased out through hypnosis are more accurate and trustworthy because they have been sealed away, untouched, behind a wall of “psychological repression.” Scientists, in contrast, see hypnosis as an invitation to psychological suggestion: the hypnotist can cue, and the subject can “recover,” whatever type of memory they hope to find.

In his novel In Search of Lost Time, Marcel Proust portrayed sensory memory as uniquely true because, unlike other forms of memory, it doesn’t change with time. To Proust, smell memory is immutable and inherently trustworthy. Smell-evoked memories are unimpeachable links to past events. Whitley Strieber takes the Proustian ball and runs with it: he repeatedly invokes smells as evidence that his abduction was real.

Strieber’s “abduction” took place on December 26, 1985. When the aliens proposed to insert a needle into his brain he objected, fearing brain damage.
One of them, I think it was the one I had identified earlier as the woman [alien], said, ‘What can we do to help you stop screaming?’ [. . .] My reply was unexpected. I heard myself say, ‘You could let me smell you.’ I was embarrassed; this is not a normal request, and it bothered me. But it made a great deal of sense, as I have afterward realized.

The one to my right replied, ‘Oh, OK, I can do that,’ in a similar voice, speaking very rapidly, and held his hand against my face, cradling my head with his other hand. The odor was distinct, and gave me exactly what I needed, an anchor in reality. It remained the most convincing aspect of the whole memory, because that odor was completely indistinguishable from a real one. It did not seem in any way a dream experience or a hallucination. I remembered it as an actual smell.
So what does an alien visitor smell like?
There was a slight scent of cardboard to it, as if the sleeve of the coverall that was partly pressed against my face were made of some substance like paper. The hand itself had a faint but distinctly organic sourness in its odor. It was not a human smell, but it was unmistakably the smell of something alive. There was a subtle overtone that seemed a little like cinnamon.

The next thing I knew, there was a bang and a flash, and I realized that they have performed the proposed operation on my head.

In the weeks that follow, Strieber is distressed about the incident and begins to doubt his own sanity.
Then, quite suddenly once afternoon, I recalled the smell. Their smell. It came back to me as clearly as if I had inhaled it not a moment before. More than anything except discovering that I was not alone with my experience, that totally real memory saved me from going stark raving mad.
Thank heaven for the solid anchor of Proustian smell memory!

Three months later, Strieber recalls his abduction under hypnosis:
I’m sitting on a bench in a little room. [Sniffs.] And it smells funny. Smells somethin’ like cheese in here. Smells kind of nasty, to tell you the truth. It’s not clean in here.
Cheese? What cheese? Here’s all he said about smell in his original description: “I seem to remember that the room was stuffy and the air quite dry . . .” So this olfactory detail—that the UFO’s reception room smelled like cheese—is an entirely new feature brought up under hypnosis. Strieber has just revised his “totally real” smell memory. Later, in the course of reflecting on the hypnosis session, he revises it even further:
The space I entered smelled like warm Cheddar cheese with a hint of sulfur. This sulfur odor has been reported by others.
So “stuffy” becomes “cheese” which becomes “warm Cheddar cheese with a hint of sulfur.” In other words, he subtly re-tunes his story to agree with other published accounts of alien abduction.

Meanwhile, Strieber introduces another Proustian revelation: the alien’s clothing “opened the door to the past. And it did this via my sense of smell.” How? Back in his apartment after the abduction, he senses the visitors again:
I felt their presence. It was palpable. Most upsetting, I could smell them. I could smell a distinct odor as if of smoldering cardboard, and it was familiar from the past. [...] Until now, though, I had not understood its significance.
The significance is that 12 or 13 years earlier he smelled smoldering cardboard one night and saw a small figure with a red light in its hand dashing through the house. He didn’t realize it at the time but this was his first brush with aliens.

Once again, Strieber edits his supposedly unshakable Proustian smell memory. The smell of the visitor’s coverall—originally a “slight scent of cardboard”—has now become “a distinct odor as if of smoldering cardboard.” (Smoldering? Were the alien’s clothes on fire?)

The effect is to buttress his newly revealed past of lifelong encounters with aliens. Or, as he puts it,
Odor is an excellent trigger of memory, and the odor of smoldering seemed to unlock a lot of doors.
Indeed. How convenient for Whitley Strieber that smell memory—a la Proust—is always true, even as he shades the recollections of it to suit his purpose.

Thursday, March 12, 2009

I Smell Dead People: Blue Moon Edition


Whoa—here’s the second month in a row with a Friday the Thirteenth. Strikes me as rare. So let’s celebrate with another not-for-the-nervous roundup of ISDP.

On February 23rd, Pedro Lopez was renovating the house he just bought in Fontana, California—it had been unoccupied for about three years. While repairing the roof he smelled “a foul odor” coming from the chimney and checked it out with a flashlight. Inside the chimney he found a dead body.

A few days later, with the help of medical x-rays, police identified the remains as those of a 48-year-old homeless man who disappeared two years ago. The man had a history of arrests in the area and a petty theft conviction. Police theorize he was probably breaking into the vacant home through the chimney when he got stuck.

On February 27, a “bad smell” complaint led authorities in Alabama to human remains in a semi-remote area, specifically a site about a mile from Possum Trot Road in Deatsville. Yes, there is such an address. Google map it yourself—it’s about 30 miles north of Montgomery.

Alabama was also in the news a couple of days earlier when “complaints of a foul odor” led police in Gadsden to a back lot where they found a hearse containing a decomposed body. The body was that of a woman who died in late 2007; her family wanted her cremated but hadn’t signed the papers or paid the funeral home. So funeral home director Harold Watson Sr. put her remains in a hearse and left it in the back lot along with some other vehicles.

Watson’s been charged with abuse of a corpse.

The next Friday the Thirteenth doesn’t roll around until November. But we’ll doubtless be back before then with the next edition of ISDP—Spring’s just around the corner and temperatures will start rising.

FLASH UPDATE March 13, 2009

Just in from yesterday’s Pittsburg Post-Gazette: A few days after an elderly lady was taken away to the hospital, her neighbors in the Beltzhoover area of Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania called the city to complain about the messy appearance of her house and a “foul odor” coming from it. Upon trying to enter the residence through a rear door, a code enforcement officer discovered a body in an advanced state of decomposition.

Basic Instinct: The Smell of Fear and Sex


Rice University psychologist Denise Chen has rapidly established herself as the leading expert on the communication of emotion through body odor. It might sound like a narrowly defined research topic, but it has enormous implications for understanding the social aspects of smell. Chen, along with her colleague Wen Zhou, has just published a pair of papers that show how BO (underarm odor) can signal fear and sexual arousal.

Both studies collected BO from male donors who wore 4 x 4 inch cloth pads in their armpits while watching 20-minute videos. In one study the videos were happy (slapstick comedy), scary (horror movies) or emotionally neutral (an educational documentary). Based on heart rate and high levels of self-reported happiness and fear during viewing, eight men were selected from a larger group to be the sweat donors. Their pads provided the “fear sweat” and “happy sweat” for the actual experiment.

In the other study, 20 hetero guys watched the educational documentary (snore . . .) and a porno video (hot!). Based largely on self-reported sexual arousal, three guys were selected as the “sexual sweat” donors. Needless to say, all donors followed meticulous protocols that avoided colognes and scented soaps as well as odiferous foods like garlic.

Who was smelling these samples of emotional sweat? In both experiments, it was young women.

In Chen’s fear study, published this month in Psychological Science, the women were shown faces and had to decide as quickly as possible whether the facial expression was happy or fearful. The faces were from a computer generated continuum in which an actor’s face was morphed from a happy expression to a fearful expression. The women judged the faces while smelling the various sweat samples. Happy sweat and the smell of clean pads had no effect on how women read the faces. Fear sweat, on the other hand, caused women to perceive otherwise neutral faces as fearful. It appears that the BO of fear has no effect on the perception of unambiguous facial expressions; however it can put a negative emotional spin on ambiguous expressions.

Chen’s study of sex sweat, published on New Year’s Eve in the Journal of Neuroscience, examined brain response to smells using fMRI scans. While in the scanner, women smelled four different odors: sex sweat, neutral sweat, phenylethyl alcohol (rose), and androstadienone (a chemical thought to be a human sex pheromone). Chen and Zhou found two brain areas that responded to sex sweat but not to the other three odors. One area was the right orbitofrontal cortex, a multisensory area known to be involved in smell judgments. The other was the right fusiform cortex, an area involved in the recognition of faces and voices, but not previously known to respond to smells.

These experiments, along with earlier work by Chen, establish that BO can function as a chemosignal that conveys the emotional state of the odor donor. Having ruled out counter-explanations—the intensity or pleasantness of the BO doesn’t matter, for example—Chen proposes that BO chemosignals are produced and perceived as a consequence of human evolution.

I think she’s on to something.

Wednesday, March 11, 2009

Puzzling Out Odor Receptors


A new paper in a rather specialized scientific journal has exciting news for those of us who eagerly anticipate a revolution in olfactory biotechnology.

Humans have about four hundred different olfactory receptors; other mammals have even more. There are thousands of potentially smellable volatile molecules in the world. Ever since the discovery of the olfactory receptor genes in 1991 the big question has been: which odor molecules are detected by which receptors? Until we can answer that question, we cannot truly say that we understand the biological basis of odor perception.

The standard way to investigate the function of a receptor is to express it in cell culture—that is, one inserts the receptor gene into a yeast cell, for example, and the yeast cell obligingly reads the new DNA, creates the receptor, and places it in the cell membrane all ready to go. Do this for enough different receptors and soon you can see which of them respond to rose alcohol, which to vanillin, etc. When automated on an industrial scale this is called high-throughput screening—a standard procedure in pharmaceutical research.

Olfactory receptors have proven exceptionally difficult to express. We’ve been able to match odors to receptors here and there in only about 50 instances; to make real progress we need to do it thousands of times under standard conditions. Recently Dr. Hiro Matsunami’s lab at Duke University created cell lines and test protocols suitable for high-throughput screening. This week they reported on the first large-scale matching of receptors to odor molecules.

Their results are in the March 3rd issue of Science Signaling. They tested 219 mouse receptors and 245 human receptors against 93 different odorants. Some receptors didn’t respond to any of the odorants; others responded to several. Some odorants activated only a couple of receptors; other activated many. As you can imagine, analyzing data on this scale is a challenge.

Ultimately, the Duke group wants to predict which odor receptors are activated by which molecules. They created a big database of odor molecules and used statistical techniques to extract a few physical properties that predict similar receptor responses. On the other hand they created an olfactory receptor database and statistical means of grouping receptors that respond to similar odors. They can now begin to discern which sort of molecules match up to which sort of receptors. Although their conclusions are abstract and very tentative, the Duke group has taken the first step toward making sense of high-throughput data and answering the Big Question.

On a practical level, their challenge is like the one you face when doing a jigsaw puzzle without the knowing the final picture. First, you dump the pieces on the table and start sorting. Light blue pieces with streaks of white go in one pile—they could be sky with clouds or whitecaps on ocean waves. Dappled brown and green pieces go in another pile—they might be tree leaves or a forest path. Pieces with straight sides go in a third pile—they’re the edges of the picture. In other words, you can start sorting without knowing exactly where the pieces fit in the picture.

Substitute “eigenvalue sum from van der Waals weighted distance matrix” for “light blue pieces with streaks of white” and you get an idea of what the Duke group is up to. The fun comes once we get the puzzle put together—when we can match every molecule to a receptor and vice versa. Then we can design highly specific odor blockers and odor enhancers, and even, perhaps, predict what perfumes a person will like. Stuart Firestein and I outlined some of the possibilities in a Nature Neuroscience paper which you can download here.